Bug #40861 for Mail-DKIM: Tests fail with v6 nameservers in resolv.conf

Wed Nov 12 09:22:21 2008 peter [...] pramberger.at - Ticket created

Subject:	Tests fail with v6 nameservers in resolv.conf
Date:	Wed, 12 Nov 2008 15:21:36 +0100
To:	bug-Mail-DKIM [...] rt.cpan.org
From:	Peter Pramberger <peter [...] pramberger.at>

Hi, I'm not sure if this is Mail::DKIMs fault. Anyway the policy and verifier tests fail if there are IPv6 resolvers configured on the system. Mail-DKIM-0.32 This is perl, v5.8.8 built for x86_64-linux-thread-multi on CentOS 5.2 DEBUG: PERL_DL_NONLAZY=1 /usr/bin/perl "-MExtUtils::Command::MM" "-e" "test_harness(0, 'blib/lib', 'blib/arch')" t/*.t DEBUG: t/Mail-DKIM..................ok DEBUG: t/policy..................... DEBUG: # Failed test 'not the default policy' DEBUG: # in t/policy.t at line 21. DEBUG: # Looks like you failed 1 test of 12. DEBUG: dubious DEBUG: Test returned status 1 (wstat 256, 0x100) DEBUG: DIED. FAILED test 4 DEBUG: Failed 1/12 tests, 91.67% okay DEBUG: t/signature..................ok DEBUG: t/signer.....................ok DEBUG: t/signer_policy..............ok DEBUG: t/simple_canonicalization....ok DEBUG: t/textwrap...................ok DEBUG: t/verifier................... DEBUG: # Failed test 'result() works and gave expected answer' DEBUG: # in t/verifier.t at line 28. DEBUG: DEBUG: # Failed test ''mine_ietf01_1.txt' should 'pass'' DEBUG: # in t/verifier.t at line 169. DEBUG: DEBUG: # Failed test ''mine_ietf01_2.txt' should 'pass'' DEBUG: # in t/verifier.t at line 169. DEBUG: DEBUG: # Failed test ''mine_ietf01_3.txt' should 'pass'' DEBUG: # in t/verifier.t at line 169. DEBUG: DEBUG: # Failed test ''mine_ietf01_4.txt' should 'pass'' DEBUG: # in t/verifier.t at line 169. DEBUG: DEBUG: # Failed test ''mine_ietf05_1.txt' should 'pass'' DEBUG: # in t/verifier.t at line 169. DEBUG: DEBUG: # Failed test ''good_ietf00_1.txt' should 'pass'' DEBUG: # in t/verifier.t at line 169. DEBUG: DEBUG: # Failed test ''good_ietf00_2.txt' should 'pass'' DEBUG: # in t/verifier.t at line 169. DEBUG: DEBUG: # Failed test ''good_ietf00_3.txt' should 'pass'' DEBUG: # in t/verifier.t at line 169. DEBUG: DEBUG: # Failed test ''good_ietf00_4.txt' should 'pass'' DEBUG: # in t/verifier.t at line 169. DEBUG: DEBUG: # Failed test ''good_ietf00_5.txt' should 'pass'' DEBUG: # in t/verifier.t at line 169. DEBUG: DEBUG: # Failed test ''good_ietf01_1.txt' should 'pass'' DEBUG: # in t/verifier.t at line 169. DEBUG: DEBUG: # Failed test ''good_ietf01_2.txt' should 'pass'' DEBUG: # in t/verifier.t at line 169. DEBUG: DEBUG: # Failed test ''good_rfc4871_3.txt' should 'pass'' DEBUG: # in t/verifier.t at line 169. DEBUG: DEBUG: # Failed test ''good_rfc4871_4.txt' should 'pass'' DEBUG: # in t/verifier.t at line 169. DEBUG: DEBUG: # Failed test ''good_1878523.txt' should 'pass'' DEBUG: # in t/verifier.t at line 169. DEBUG: DEBUG: # Failed test ''multiple_1.txt' should 'pass'' DEBUG: # in t/verifier.t at line 169. DEBUG: DEBUG: # Failed test ''multiple_2.txt' should 'pass'' DEBUG: # in t/verifier.t at line 169. DEBUG: DEBUG: # Failed test 'second signature is 'pass'' DEBUG: # in t/verifier.t at line 54. DEBUG: DEBUG: # Failed test 'third signature is 'fail'' DEBUG: # in t/verifier.t at line 55. DEBUG: DEBUG: # Failed test ''good_qp_1.txt' should 'pass'' DEBUG: # in t/verifier.t at line 169. DEBUG: DEBUG: # Failed test ''good_qp_2.txt' should 'pass'' DEBUG: # in t/verifier.t at line 169. DEBUG: DEBUG: # Failed test ''good_qp_3.txt' should 'pass'' DEBUG: # in t/verifier.t at line 169. DEBUG: DEBUG: # Failed test ''bad_ietf01_1.txt' should 'fail'' DEBUG: # in t/verifier.t at line 169. DEBUG: DEBUG: # Failed test 'determined body had been altered' DEBUG: # in t/verifier.t at line 61. DEBUG: DEBUG: # Failed test ''bad_ietf01_2.txt' should 'fail'' DEBUG: # in t/verifier.t at line 169. DEBUG: DEBUG: # Failed test 'determined message had been altered' DEBUG: # in t/verifier.t at line 63. DEBUG: DEBUG: # Failed test ''bad_ietf01_3.txt' should 'fail'' DEBUG: # in t/verifier.t at line 169. DEBUG: DEBUG: # Failed test 'determined RSA failure' DEBUG: # in t/verifier.t at line 65. DEBUG: DEBUG: # Failed test ''bad_1.txt' should 'fail'' DEBUG: # in t/verifier.t at line 169. DEBUG: DEBUG: # Failed test ''bad_1878954.txt' should 'fail'' DEBUG: # in t/verifier.t at line 169. DEBUG: DEBUG: # Failed test ''good_dk_gmail.txt' should 'pass'' DEBUG: # in t/verifier.t at line 169. DEBUG: DEBUG: # Failed test ''good_dk_yahoo.txt' should 'pass'' DEBUG: # in t/verifier.t at line 169. DEBUG: DEBUG: # Failed test ''good_dk_1.txt' should 'pass'' DEBUG: # in t/verifier.t at line 169. DEBUG: DEBUG: # Failed test ''good_dk_2.txt' should 'pass'' DEBUG: # in t/verifier.t at line 169. DEBUG: DEBUG: # Failed test ''good_dk_3.txt' should 'pass'' DEBUG: # in t/verifier.t at line 169. DEBUG: DEBUG: # Failed test ''good_dk_4.txt' should 'pass'' DEBUG: # in t/verifier.t at line 169. DEBUG: DEBUG: # Failed test ''good_dk_5.txt' should 'pass'' DEBUG: # in t/verifier.t at line 169. DEBUG: DEBUG: # Failed test ''good_dk_6.txt' should 'pass'' DEBUG: # in t/verifier.t at line 169. DEBUG: DEBUG: # Failed test ''good_dk_7.txt' should 'pass'' DEBUG: # in t/verifier.t at line 169. DEBUG: DEBUG: # Failed test ''dk_headers_1.txt' should 'pass'' DEBUG: # in t/verifier.t at line 169. DEBUG: DEBUG: # Failed test ''dk_headers_2.txt' should 'pass'' DEBUG: # in t/verifier.t at line 169. DEBUG: DEBUG: # Failed test ''dk_multiple_1.txt' should 'pass'' DEBUG: # in t/verifier.t at line 169. DEBUG: DEBUG: # Failed test 'first signature is 'pass'' DEBUG: # in t/verifier.t at line 95. DEBUG: DEBUG: # Failed test 'second signature is 'pass'' DEBUG: # in t/verifier.t at line 96. DEBUG: DEBUG: # Failed test ''no_body_1.txt' should 'pass'' DEBUG: # in t/verifier.t at line 169. DEBUG: DEBUG: # Failed test ''no_body_2.txt' should 'pass'' DEBUG: # in t/verifier.t at line 169. DEBUG: DEBUG: # Failed test ''no_body_3.txt' should 'pass'' DEBUG: # in t/verifier.t at line 169. DEBUG: DEBUG: # Failed test ''goodkey_1.txt' should 'pass'' DEBUG: # in t/verifier.t at line 169. DEBUG: DEBUG: # Failed test ''goodkey_2.txt' should 'pass'' DEBUG: # in t/verifier.t at line 169. DEBUG: DEBUG: # Failed test ''goodkey_3.txt' should 'pass'' DEBUG: # in t/verifier.t at line 169. DEBUG: DEBUG: # Failed test ''goodkey_4.txt' should 'pass'' DEBUG: # in t/verifier.t at line 169. DEBUG: # Looks like you failed 52 tests of 83. DEBUG: dubious DEBUG: Test returned status 52 (wstat 13312, 0x3400) DEBUG: DIED. FAILED tests 5-22, 24-35, 37-48, 51, 53-57, 66-69 DEBUG: Failed 52/83 tests, 37.35% okay (less 1 skipped test: 30 okay, 36.14%) DEBUG: Failed Test Stat Wstat Total Fail Failed List of Failed DEBUG: ------------------------------------------------------------------------------- DEBUG: t/policy.t 1 256 12 1 8.33% 4 DEBUG: t/verifier.t 52 13312 83 52 62.65% 5-22 24-35 37-48 51 53-57 66-69 DEBUG: 1 subtest skipped. DEBUG: Failed 2/8 test scripts, 75.00% okay. 53/162 subtests failed, 67.28% okay. After changing the entries to IPv4, the tests succeed: DEBUG: PERL_DL_NONLAZY=1 /usr/bin/perl "-MExtUtils::Command::MM" "-e" "test_harness(0, 'blib/lib', 'blib/arch')" t/*.t DEBUG: t/Mail-DKIM..................ok DEBUG: t/policy.....................ok DEBUG: t/signature..................ok DEBUG: t/signer.....................ok DEBUG: t/signer_policy..............ok DEBUG: t/simple_canonicalization....ok DEBUG: t/textwrap...................ok DEBUG: t/verifier...................ok DEBUG: All tests successful. DEBUG: Files=8, Tests=162, 3 wallclock secs ( 0.35 cusr + 0.18 csys = 0.53 CPU) Br, Peter

Fri Nov 14 11:49:47 2008 peter [...] pramberger.at - Correspondence added

Subject:	Re: [rt.cpan.org #40861] AutoReply: Tests fail with v6 nameservers in resolv.conf
Date:	Fri, 14 Nov 2008 17:49:37 +0100
To:	bug-Mail-DKIM [...] rt.cpan.org
From:	Peter Pramberger <peter [...] pramberger.at>

Ok, sorry - forget it. Net::DNS was missing the v6 transport layer (IO::Socket::INET6)... All tests suceed now. Br, Peter Bugs in Mail-DKIM via RT schrieb am 12.11.2008 15:22: Show quoted text

> Greetings, > > This message has been automatically generated in response to the > creation of a trouble ticket regarding: > "Tests fail with v6 nameservers in resolv.conf", > a summary of which appears below. > > There is no need to reply to this message right now. Your ticket has been > assigned an ID of [rt.cpan.org #40861]. Your ticket is accessible > on the web at: > > http://rt.cpan.org/Ticket/Display.html?id=40861 > > Please include the string: > > [rt.cpan.org #40861] > > in the subject line of all future correspondence about this issue. To do so, > you may reply to this message. > > Thank you, > bug-Mail-DKIM@rt.cpan.org > > ------------------------------------------------------------------------- > Hi, > > I'm not sure if this is Mail::DKIMs fault. Anyway the policy and > verifier tests fail if there are IPv6 resolvers configured on the system. > > Mail-DKIM-0.32 > This is perl, v5.8.8 built for x86_64-linux-thread-multi > on CentOS 5.2 > > DEBUG: PERL_DL_NONLAZY=1 /usr/bin/perl "-MExtUtils::Command::MM" "-e" > "test_harness(0, 'blib/lib', 'blib/arch')" t/*.t > DEBUG: t/Mail-DKIM..................ok > DEBUG: t/policy..................... > DEBUG: # Failed test 'not the default policy' > DEBUG: # in t/policy.t at line 21. > DEBUG: # Looks like you failed 1 test of 12. > DEBUG: dubious > DEBUG: Test returned status 1 (wstat 256, 0x100) > DEBUG: DIED. FAILED test 4 > DEBUG: Failed 1/12 tests, 91.67% okay > DEBUG: t/signature..................ok > DEBUG: t/signer.....................ok > DEBUG: t/signer_policy..............ok > DEBUG: t/simple_canonicalization....ok > DEBUG: t/textwrap...................ok > DEBUG: t/verifier................... > DEBUG: # Failed test 'result() works and gave expected answer' > DEBUG: # in t/verifier.t at line 28. > DEBUG: > DEBUG: # Failed test ''mine_ietf01_1.txt' should 'pass'' > DEBUG: # in t/verifier.t at line 169. > DEBUG: > DEBUG: # Failed test ''mine_ietf01_2.txt' should 'pass'' > DEBUG: # in t/verifier.t at line 169. > DEBUG: > DEBUG: # Failed test ''mine_ietf01_3.txt' should 'pass'' > DEBUG: # in t/verifier.t at line 169. > DEBUG: > DEBUG: # Failed test ''mine_ietf01_4.txt' should 'pass'' > DEBUG: # in t/verifier.t at line 169. > DEBUG: > DEBUG: # Failed test ''mine_ietf05_1.txt' should 'pass'' > DEBUG: # in t/verifier.t at line 169. > DEBUG: > DEBUG: # Failed test ''good_ietf00_1.txt' should 'pass'' > DEBUG: # in t/verifier.t at line 169. > DEBUG: > DEBUG: # Failed test ''good_ietf00_2.txt' should 'pass'' > DEBUG: # in t/verifier.t at line 169. > DEBUG: > DEBUG: # Failed test ''good_ietf00_3.txt' should 'pass'' > DEBUG: # in t/verifier.t at line 169. > DEBUG: > DEBUG: # Failed test ''good_ietf00_4.txt' should 'pass'' > DEBUG: # in t/verifier.t at line 169. > DEBUG: > DEBUG: # Failed test ''good_ietf00_5.txt' should 'pass'' > DEBUG: # in t/verifier.t at line 169. > DEBUG: > DEBUG: # Failed test ''good_ietf01_1.txt' should 'pass'' > DEBUG: # in t/verifier.t at line 169. > DEBUG: > DEBUG: # Failed test ''good_ietf01_2.txt' should 'pass'' > DEBUG: # in t/verifier.t at line 169. > DEBUG: > DEBUG: # Failed test ''good_rfc4871_3.txt' should 'pass'' > DEBUG: # in t/verifier.t at line 169. > DEBUG: > DEBUG: # Failed test ''good_rfc4871_4.txt' should 'pass'' > DEBUG: # in t/verifier.t at line 169. > DEBUG: > DEBUG: # Failed test ''good_1878523.txt' should 'pass'' > DEBUG: # in t/verifier.t at line 169. > DEBUG: > DEBUG: # Failed test ''multiple_1.txt' should 'pass'' > DEBUG: # in t/verifier.t at line 169. > DEBUG: > DEBUG: # Failed test ''multiple_2.txt' should 'pass'' > DEBUG: # in t/verifier.t at line 169. > DEBUG: > DEBUG: # Failed test 'second signature is 'pass'' > DEBUG: # in t/verifier.t at line 54. > DEBUG: > DEBUG: # Failed test 'third signature is 'fail'' > DEBUG: # in t/verifier.t at line 55. > DEBUG: > DEBUG: # Failed test ''good_qp_1.txt' should 'pass'' > DEBUG: # in t/verifier.t at line 169. > DEBUG: > DEBUG: # Failed test ''good_qp_2.txt' should 'pass'' > DEBUG: # in t/verifier.t at line 169. > DEBUG: > DEBUG: # Failed test ''good_qp_3.txt' should 'pass'' > DEBUG: # in t/verifier.t at line 169. > DEBUG: > DEBUG: # Failed test ''bad_ietf01_1.txt' should 'fail'' > DEBUG: # in t/verifier.t at line 169. > DEBUG: > DEBUG: # Failed test 'determined body had been altered' > DEBUG: # in t/verifier.t at line 61. > DEBUG: > DEBUG: # Failed test ''bad_ietf01_2.txt' should 'fail'' > DEBUG: # in t/verifier.t at line 169. > DEBUG: > DEBUG: # Failed test 'determined message had been altered' > DEBUG: # in t/verifier.t at line 63. > DEBUG: > DEBUG: # Failed test ''bad_ietf01_3.txt' should 'fail'' > DEBUG: # in t/verifier.t at line 169. > DEBUG: > DEBUG: # Failed test 'determined RSA failure' > DEBUG: # in t/verifier.t at line 65. > DEBUG: > DEBUG: # Failed test ''bad_1.txt' should 'fail'' > DEBUG: # in t/verifier.t at line 169. > DEBUG: > DEBUG: # Failed test ''bad_1878954.txt' should 'fail'' > DEBUG: # in t/verifier.t at line 169. > DEBUG: > DEBUG: # Failed test ''good_dk_gmail.txt' should 'pass'' > DEBUG: # in t/verifier.t at line 169. > DEBUG: > DEBUG: # Failed test ''good_dk_yahoo.txt' should 'pass'' > DEBUG: # in t/verifier.t at line 169. > DEBUG: > DEBUG: # Failed test ''good_dk_1.txt' should 'pass'' > DEBUG: # in t/verifier.t at line 169. > DEBUG: > DEBUG: # Failed test ''good_dk_2.txt' should 'pass'' > DEBUG: # in t/verifier.t at line 169. > DEBUG: > DEBUG: # Failed test ''good_dk_3.txt' should 'pass'' > DEBUG: # in t/verifier.t at line 169. > DEBUG: > DEBUG: # Failed test ''good_dk_4.txt' should 'pass'' > DEBUG: # in t/verifier.t at line 169. > DEBUG: > DEBUG: # Failed test ''good_dk_5.txt' should 'pass'' > DEBUG: # in t/verifier.t at line 169. > DEBUG: > DEBUG: # Failed test ''good_dk_6.txt' should 'pass'' > DEBUG: # in t/verifier.t at line 169. > DEBUG: > DEBUG: # Failed test ''good_dk_7.txt' should 'pass'' > DEBUG: # in t/verifier.t at line 169. > DEBUG: > DEBUG: # Failed test ''dk_headers_1.txt' should 'pass'' > DEBUG: # in t/verifier.t at line 169. > DEBUG: > DEBUG: # Failed test ''dk_headers_2.txt' should 'pass'' > DEBUG: # in t/verifier.t at line 169. > DEBUG: > DEBUG: # Failed test ''dk_multiple_1.txt' should 'pass'' > DEBUG: # in t/verifier.t at line 169. > DEBUG: > DEBUG: # Failed test 'first signature is 'pass'' > DEBUG: # in t/verifier.t at line 95. > DEBUG: > DEBUG: # Failed test 'second signature is 'pass'' > DEBUG: # in t/verifier.t at line 96. > DEBUG: > DEBUG: # Failed test ''no_body_1.txt' should 'pass'' > DEBUG: # in t/verifier.t at line 169. > DEBUG: > DEBUG: # Failed test ''no_body_2.txt' should 'pass'' > DEBUG: # in t/verifier.t at line 169. > DEBUG: > DEBUG: # Failed test ''no_body_3.txt' should 'pass'' > DEBUG: # in t/verifier.t at line 169. > DEBUG: > DEBUG: # Failed test ''goodkey_1.txt' should 'pass'' > DEBUG: # in t/verifier.t at line 169. > DEBUG: > DEBUG: # Failed test ''goodkey_2.txt' should 'pass'' > DEBUG: # in t/verifier.t at line 169. > DEBUG: > DEBUG: # Failed test ''goodkey_3.txt' should 'pass'' > DEBUG: # in t/verifier.t at line 169. > DEBUG: > DEBUG: # Failed test ''goodkey_4.txt' should 'pass'' > DEBUG: # in t/verifier.t at line 169. > DEBUG: # Looks like you failed 52 tests of 83. > DEBUG: dubious > DEBUG: Test returned status 52 (wstat 13312, 0x3400) > DEBUG: DIED. FAILED tests 5-22, 24-35, 37-48, 51, 53-57, 66-69 > DEBUG: Failed 52/83 tests, 37.35% okay (less 1 skipped test: 30 okay, > 36.14%) > DEBUG: Failed Test Stat Wstat Total Fail Failed List of Failed > DEBUG: > ------------------------------------------------------------------------------- > DEBUG: t/policy.t 1 256 12 1 8.33% 4 > DEBUG: t/verifier.t 52 13312 83 52 62.65% 5-22 24-35 37-48 51 > 53-57 66-69 > DEBUG: 1 subtest skipped. > DEBUG: Failed 2/8 test scripts, 75.00% okay. 53/162 subtests failed, > 67.28% okay. > > After changing the entries to IPv4, the tests succeed: > > DEBUG: PERL_DL_NONLAZY=1 /usr/bin/perl "-MExtUtils::Command::MM" "-e" > "test_harness(0, 'blib/lib', 'blib/arch')" t/*.t > DEBUG: t/Mail-DKIM..................ok > DEBUG: t/policy.....................ok > DEBUG: t/signature..................ok > DEBUG: t/signer.....................ok > DEBUG: t/signer_policy..............ok > DEBUG: t/simple_canonicalization....ok > DEBUG: t/textwrap...................ok > DEBUG: t/verifier...................ok > DEBUG: All tests successful. > DEBUG: Files=8, Tests=162, 3 wallclock secs ( 0.35 cusr + 0.18 csys = > 0.53 CPU) > > > Br, > Peter

Mon Nov 17 09:02:35 2008 jason [...] long.name - Taken

Mon Nov 17 09:03:03 2008 jason [...] long.name - Correspondence added

On Fri Nov 14 11:49:47 2008, peter@pramberger.at wrote: Show quoted text

> Ok, sorry - forget it. Net::DNS was missing the v6 transport layer > (IO::Socket::INET6)... > > All tests suceed now.

Excellent. Thanks for the follow-up. Jason

Mon Nov 17 09:03:06 2008 The RT System itself - Status changed from 'new' to 'open'

Mon Nov 17 09:03:09 2008 jason [...] long.name - Status changed from 'open' to 'resolved'