Bug #35154 for Getopt-Euclid: minimal_keys does not work when Pod is in a module

Thu Apr 17 11:49:54 2008 bitcard_ok [...] alvar.a-blast.org - Ticket created

Subject:

minimal_keys does not work when Pod is in a module

Hi, when the Pod is inside a module, the minimal_keys option is ignored. Ciao Alvar

Thu Apr 24 13:07:59 2008 bitcard_ok [...] alvar.a-blast.org - Correspondence added

From:

bitcard_ok [...] alvar.a-blast.org

Hi, On Do. 17. Apr. 2008, 11:49:54, alvar-f wrote: Show quoted text

> when the Pod is inside a module, the minimal_keys option is ignored.

it works, when doing the following in the script: use MyModule::WithPod qw(:minimal_keys); Ciao Alvar

Wed Apr 15 08:08:14 2009 kgalinsky [...] gmail.com - Correspondence added

Hi Alvar, Can I close this ticket? It seems like you were trying to do the following: ---MyModule.pm package MyModule; use Getopt::Euclid qw(:minimal_keys); =head1 OPTIONS =over =item [-]-o[ption] <o> =back =cut 1; ---my_script.pl use MyModule; print $ARGV{option}; # DOESN'T WORK!!! --- I should let Damian comment on this, but IMHO that is the proper behavior. As you have discovered, what you should do is: ---MyModule.pm package MyModule; use Getopt::Euclid; ... ---my_script.pl use MyModule qw(:minimal_keys); ... --- Anyway, I'll leave this ticket open for a few days before closing it. If you feel that module should be able to specify how Getopt::Euclid loads the options specified in the module, I'll see about setting this to a feature request. Best, -Kevin

Wed Apr 15 08:08:15 2009 The RT System itself - Status changed from 'new' to 'open'

Wed Apr 15 08:08:19 2009 kgalinsky [...] gmail.com - Taken

Sun Apr 19 08:38:15 2009 kgalinsky [...] gmail.com - Correspondence added

This is not a bug. Have made note that one potential feature request is to allow modules to specify how the options in their pod is exported.

Sun Apr 19 08:38:17 2009 kgalinsky [...] gmail.com - Status changed from 'open' to 'rejected'